Shower Doors vs. Shower Curtains: Which is Right for You?

So, you’ve decided to install a combined shower-bath. Great choice!  

But now comes the big question: should you go with a shower curtain or shower door? 

The barrier you choose can make a big impact on your overall look, feel, and functionality of your bathroom. You want something that keeps water in, adds to the aesthetic, and fits your lifestyle. 

Some people love the softness and flexibility of a patterned or textured shower curtain, while others prefer the no-nonsense efficiency of a sheer pane of glass. 

In this post, we’ll go over the pros and cons of both options to help you make the best decision for your space. 

The Case for Shower Curtains

Shower curtains have been a go-to for decades—and for good reason. They’re budget-friendly, easy to install, and incredibly versatile. 

Pros of Shower Curtains

Budget-Friendly 

When comparing a shower curtain vs glass door, curtains win in terms of cost. You can grab a basic one for under $20 or spend a little more for something designer-worthy, all without stretching your budget. 

Easy to Install 

A shower curtain requires minimal DIY skills. Simply use a walk-in shower curtain rod or a tension rod, add some hooks, and you’re set. Plus, if you’re renting, you can easily remove it when you move out. 

Great for Smaller Bathrooms 

For compact bathrooms, the shower curtain vs shower door debate leans in favor of curtains. They don’t need extra clearance to open and can make tight spaces feel less crowded. 

Good for Kids and Pets 

If you have young kids or pets that need baths, a shower curtain is more practical. You can easily pull it aside without the hassle of maneuvering around a heavy glass door. 

Lots of Style Options 

Shower curtains come in an endless variety of choices, from bold and eye-catching to subtle and elegant. You can even change them seasonally if you like to switch things up. 

Cons of Shower Curtains 

Less Effective at Containing Water 

One of the biggest downsides to shower curtains is that they’re not always great at keeping water inside the tub or shower area. If they’re not long enough or properly positioned, you can end up with water pooling on the bathroom floor. 

Mold and Mildew Build-Up 

Shower curtains, especially fabric ones, are prone to mold and mildew. Even if you choose a mildew-resistant option, you’ll still need to wash or replace them regularly. 

Can Look Less Luxurious 

While there are stylish shower curtains out there, they often don’t have the same upscale feel as glass shower doors. If you’re going for a high-end, modern look, a curtain might not give you the aesthetic you want. 

The Case for Shower Doors 

Glass doors are the go-to for those after a spa-like aesthetic. Their sleek lines and polished finish add a level of sophistication that’s hard to replicate. 

Pros of Shower Doors 

Sleek, Modern Look 

If you want your bathroom to feel more luxurious, shower doors are the way to go. Frameless glass doors, in particular, create a clean, minimalist look that can make your space feel open and elegant. 

Better at Keeping Water Inside 

Unlike curtains, glass doors provide a solid barrier, so you don’t have to worry about water splashing out. It’s especially helpful if you have a walk-in shower without a tub. 

Long-Lasting and Durable 

Good quality glass doors can last for years with minimal wear and tear. They’re sturdy and resistant to mold and mildew. 

Easier to Clean 

While shower doors do require regular cleaning to prevent water spots and soap scum, they don’t hold onto moisture the same way curtains do. All you need is a simple squeegee and a glass cleaner to keep them in good shape. 

Can Increase Home Value 

If you’re thinking about resale value, shower doors can be a worthwhile investment. Many buyers prefer them over curtains, more so in master bathrooms. 

Cons of Shower Doors 

More Expensive 

A bathtub glass doors vs shower curtains comparison often comes down to price. Custom or frameless doors can be pricey, and installation adds to the cost. 

Difficult Installation 

Installing shower doors requires professional help in most cases. This can be a hassle if you’re working with an unusual shower size or layout. 

Requires More Maintenance 

Although shower doors are easier to clean than curtains in some ways, they do require regular upkeep. Water spots, streaks, and soap scum can build up quickly. If you don’t keep up with cleaning, the glass can start to look cloudy. 

Takes Up More Space 

Shower doors may not be the best choice for small bathrooms or tight spaces. Swinging doors, in particular, need extra room to open outward. Even sliding doors require a wide enough shower opening and can sometimes feel bulky in compact layouts. 

Less Flexibility 

Once installed, a shower door is a permanent fixture, unlike a curtain that you can easily replace. If you ever decide to remove the shower door and replace it with curtain, it will require some effort and additional adjustments. 

What’s Best for Your Bathroom? 

There’s no universal right or wrong here. It’s all about what fits your space, budget, and lifestyle. Here’s what you’ll need to consider. 

1) Budget 

If you’re doing a quick, budget-friendly update, a shower curtain vs shower door decision will likely favor the curtain. If you’re already investing in a remodel, a glass shower door vs shower curtain upgrade could be worth it. 

2) Space and Layout 

Small bathrooms can benefit from the visual openness of glass doors, but sometimes, a simple curtain makes the space feel less cramped. If you have a tight layout where a door might hit the toilet or vanity, go for a curtain or sliding door. 

3) Maintenance Level 

Shower curtains are low-stakes when it comes to cleaning — you can toss them in the washer. Glass doors, on the other hand, require more frequent wiping to avoid spots and streaks. 

The Bottom Line 

If you’re still undecided, think about how you use your bathroom daily. Do you prioritize convenience, or are you willing to put in a little more effort for aesthetics and durability? Either way, there’s one-size-fits-all solution—just what works best for you. 

Ready for a shower upgrade? At Lifespan Home Improvement, we specialize in custom bathroom remodeling designed around your unique needs and preferences. Our expert team is here to bring your vision to life—on time, on budget, and with high-quality craftsmanship. 

Contact us today!