The Pros and Cons of a Tub-to-Shower Conversion

Russ Tychsen
May 25, 2024

Of the many things you can do to make your bathroom work better for you, a tub-to-shower conversion is a popular upgrade. Perhaps you don’t really need a tub, or you’re looking for a larger, more accessible shower option. Or maybe you’re simply ready to refresh your bathroom’s look with a modern twist. 

While tub-to-shower conversions are usually quick and budget-friendly, the idea of permanently altering a key bathroom feature might seem daunting. Let’s dive into the advantages and disadvantages to help you decide if this renovation suits your space.

The Pros of Tub-to-Shower Conversions 

Homeowners opt for tub-to-shower conversions for several reasons. Some of the most noteworthy benefits of this project are as follows. 

1. Increased Accessibility

A shower makes getting in and out of the bath a lot easier than a tub. If someone in your home is older or has trouble moving around, a walk-in shower can reduce the risk of slipping and falling.  

Plus, it’s much easier to customize a shower for those with limited mobility. Consider adding features like a doorless walk-in shower, grab rails, or a built-in seat to create an accessible and safe space; perfect for anyone who might need some extra help. 

2. Space-Saving Convenience

If your bathtub feels bulky and makes your bathroom look cramped, converting to a shower could be a smart solution. Installing a square shower unit doesn’t take up much space and is a simple way to leverage what you’ve got. 

By ditching the large tub for a shower, you’ll open up the area and make it easier to move around.  You can also use the newfound space to add handy features, like a small vanity for additional storage. 

3. Increased Sense of Space

Showers with clear glass doors can visually enlarge even the smallest bathrooms. The transparency allows light to circulate freely, creating an illusion of more space and contributing to a more inviting atmosphere. When done correctly, a tub-to-shower conversion can transform your bathroom into a spa-like retreat.

4. Reduced Water Usage

Filling up a bathtub takes a ton of water. Sure, you could fill it up less, but to get a good wash, you generally need quite a bit of water.  

However, showers don’t take nearly as much water. A tub-to-shower conversion can save you a good amount on your water costs each year. If you have a big family who all use the bathroom, these savings will quickly add up and lighten the load on your wallet. Many people don’t consider this when thinking about converting from a tub to a shower, but who doesn’t like saving money and having a little extra in their pocket? 

5. Better Home Resale Value

Many homebuyers are on the lookout for bathrooms that look like and function as relaxing oases. As such, if you plan on selling your home in the future, upgrading to a walk-in shower can get you a return on investment (ROI) of about 54.6 percent. 

While some remodeling projects can be pricey and don’t always pay off, this particular change tends to justify the expense. In most cases, you can expect to recover at least somewhat more than what you spent on the upgrade when it’s time to sell your home. 

The Cons of a Tub-to-Shower Conversion 

Even with the tub-to-shower conversion benefits we have outlined above, there are a few potential downsides and challenges to keep in mind. 

1. No More Baths for Kids 

This might not be a big deal if you have another bathtub in a different bathroom, but if your home has only one bathroom, you need to think about whether you still need a tub for your kids. 

Children often prefer baths, and for parents, it’s usually easier to bathe young kids in a tub than in a shower. In case your children are still little, you may want to hold onto the bathtub for a while longer, at least until they’re a bit older. 

2. No Tub for Soaking 

Do you love unwinding in a hot bath after a tough day? A tub-to-shower conversion might cost you those long soaks.  

Think about whether you’ll miss the chance to unwind in a bath, even with all the perks a shower brings. A good middle ground might be to install a showerhead over the tub. This setup lets you use the shower most of the time but keeps the tub ready for those moments when you need a relaxing soak. 

3. The Risk of Splashing Water 

A walk-in shower can sometimes lead to water splashing out and creating a slippery situation outside the bathroom. You might want to consider putting up a shower curtain or door to keep the water contained. 

4. Cost of Conversion 

Converting a tub to a shower can be costly, especially if it involves extensive plumbing changes, waterproofing, and new fixtures. The costs can increase further if you opt for high-end materials or custom designs. 

Deciding If a Tub-to-Shower Conversion is Right for You 

Wondering if it’s time to swap your tub for a shower? Here’s a simple guide to help you decide. 

1. Assess Your Lifestyle and Needs 

Think about how you currently use your bathroom. If no one in your household takes baths and everyone prefers quick showers, converting to a shower might make a lot of sense. Also, account for your future needs—will accessibility become a concern as you or your family members grow older? 

2. Think About Space and Functionality 

Evaluate the space you have. A shower can make a small bathroom feel more spacious and open compared to a bulky tub. If you’re struggling with space, a conversion might be just what you need. 

3. Factor in Budget and Cost 

Figure out your budget. Conversions can range from budget-friendly to high-end, depending on the materials and features you choose. Make sure the cost aligns with your budget and the potential return on investment. 

In case you’re still on the fence, consult a tub-to-shower conversion company, like Lifestyle Bath Remodel Inc.! We’ll guide you through the scope of your project, including any potential challenges and costs. Additionally, we can show you a range of options that might fit your needs and help you visualize the outcome. 

Need a Tub-to-Shower Conversion? Let’s Talk 

A tub-to-shower conversion can be a great way to update your bathroom and improve its functionality and appeal. However, it’s important to weigh the pros and cons carefully to ensure that this renovation meets your personal preferences. Take all these factors into account to make a decision you’ll be happy with for years to come. 

Thinking about a tub-to-shower conversion but not sure where to start? Lifespan Home Improvements is here to help! Our team of tub-to-shower conversion contractors can guide you through every step of the process, from design to installation. We’ll make sure your new shower fits perfectly with your lifestyle and your home’s style. Contact us today! 

We beat any competitor by $100.

Get your free quote!

Recent articles

Share Post

Related Posts

Russ Tychsen