Which Is Better for Your Utah Bathroom: Walk-In Tubs vs Traditional Tubs?

Are you planning a bathroom remodel in Utah? 

If yes, you are probably wondering, “Traditional or walk-in bathtubs, which is better?”

This is a critical choice for homeowners in Utah, especially for a family caring for seniors or someone with a disability. It will decide the safety, comfort, and value of your new bathtub installation. 

Let’s compare these two options and see which one better suits your needs. 

What Are Walk-In Bathtubs 

Walk-in bathtubs are modified with a side door you can step through instead of climbing over the tub wall. This design helps those with limited mobility or joint pain to enjoy a soak safely and easily. 

Walk-in tubs designed for seniors come with non-slip floors, grab bars, and even handheld showers. It’s typically a must for upgrading your Utah home with ADA-compliant or senior-friendly bathrooms. 

What Are Traditional Bathtubs

You probably already have a traditional tub in one of your bathrooms. It’s a great choice for a long, relaxing soak after a tiring day. But as you have to step over the tall side wall, traditional bathtubs are not made for everyone. 

They are relatively easy to install and cost-effective compared to walk-in tubs. You can go ahead with a traditional bathtub if none of your family members have mobility issues. 

A Quick Comparison of Walk-In and Traditional Bathtubs 

Both options come with their unique benefits and drawbacks. If you plan to convert your shower into a bathtub, you should keep the following in mind. 

1. Walk-In Bathtubs Are More Accessible 

The most obvious benefit of walk-in tubs is the increased accessibility. With a side door, even those with disabilities or joint pain can easily get in and out of the tub. Many walk-in tubs come with a handheld shower, which adds to your comfort. 

Unfortunately, traditional bathtubs are not as accessible. If you are retired (or about to retire) and plan to age in place, you should consider replacing your traditional bathtub with a walk-in alternative. 

2. Walk-In Bathtubs Are Much Safer 

Safety is yet another benefit of walk-in tubs. Given that elders experience falls, and with most of them happening in bathrooms, adding a walk-in tub in your bathroom can increase safety for seniors. 

You can install walk-in tubs for seniors with additional safety features such as grab bars, a handheld shower, and a comfortable seat or bench. If you want safety for aging parents or grandparents, a walk-in bathtub with these features is a safer pick.

3. Walk-In Bathtubs Are More Comfortable 

Traditional bathtubs are bigger and designed for a comfortable, relaxing soak. With the right combination of lighting, a few scented candles, and a glass of wine, they can turn your bathroom into a spa-like retreat every evening. But getting in and out of a traditional bathtub is a challenge for those with arthritis or stiffness in their back and legs. 

On the other hand, walk-in tubs are designed for comfort. If you want to install a walk-in tub for seniors in your home, you can choose add-ons such as jets for hydrotherapy or heated backrests for relaxation.  

4. Traditional Bathtubs Lack Independence 

As you age, seemingly simple tasks become challenging, such as taking a shower. But with a walk-in bathtub, you or someone you love can maintain their privacy and independence. 

In contrast, a traditional bathtub poses many hurdles and safety risks for seniors. A walk-in bathtub is the more obvious choice if you plan to make your bathroom more senior-friendly or prepare it for aging in place.

5. Traditional Bathtubs Are Easier to Maintain 

Most Utah homes get hard water, which means your plumbing, bathroom fixtures, and bathtubs are prone to mineral buildup. Walk-in bathtubs with jets, grab bars, and doors require more regular cleaning, especially around seals, edges, and jets.

Traditional bathtubs require relatively less seal maintenance, but still need regular scrubbing using a good cleaner. Colorx, Zep, and Stardrops are some of the best bathroom foam cleaners you can use to keep your bathtub sparkling. 

6. Both Tubs Need Professional Installation 

Whether it’s a walk-in or a traditional tub, bathtub installation is not a DIY job. Every tub replacement requires careful planning and sometimes moving your existing plumbing, especially if you want to convert a regular shower into a walk-in or traditional tub. 

Many professional installers in Utah, including Lifespan Bath Remodel, offer same-day tub replacements. But sometimes, installing a walk-in tub can take longer, particularly if you need electrical runs for heated seats or jets. 

7. Traditional Bathtubs Are Less Expensive 

Depending on the material and size, a traditional bathtub can cost anywhere between $1,000 and $10,000. You will need to pay extra for installation, removal, and unexpected repairs, if any.

Walk-in tubs are typically more expensive, and depending on their size and safety features, they can set you back by $5,000 to $15,000. Again, installation may be extra. 

When you consult a professional bathtub installer, they will provide you with an estimate. It will provide a cost breakdown for the installation. Check it thoroughly and talk to your contractor if you have any doubts. 

A Walk-In or Traditional Tub: Which Is Better for You

Your choice depends on your requirements and budget. If you want to plan for aging in place or have a senior family member, a walk-in tub makes more sense. But if you have a young family with no mobility restrictions, install a traditional bathtub to create a sauna-like retreat right in your home. 

If you need something in between, install a walk-in tub with a shower. It’s your call. But do consult a bathroom remodeling contractor before going ahead with any changes. They can help you understand your options and complete the upgrade without any hiccups. 

Contact Experts at Lifespan Bath Remodel Now 

Still not sure which is better for your Utah home? Speak with one of the experts at Lifespan Bath Remodel. We can help you make the right choice, replace your old bathtub with a walk-in alternative, or convert your tub to a shower. 

Want a free estimate? Call (801) 532-2000 or fill out our online form now.