Do Tub-to-Shower Conversions Hurt Resale Value?

In most U.S. homes, you’ll find at least one bathroom with a classic tub-and-shower combo, and it’s easy to see why. Tubs are perfect for safely bathing the kids and letting you indulge in a relaxing soak whenever you feel like it.

But lately, there’s a growing trend toward bathrooms with showers only. 

A question we often hear is, “Will converting my tub into a shower hurt my home’s resale value?” Do you need a tub to get the most out of your renovation investment, or is a fancy shower enough? And when should your preferences for convenience take the driver’s seat over future sale price considerations?

Read on to see if a tub-to-shower remodel is the right choice for your home!

Understanding the Trend: Why Tub-to-Shower Conversions Are So Popular

Tub-to-shower conversions have been on the rise in recent years. Why? Because people are busy! Showers are quick, easy, and often more practical than a bathtub, especially for those with a fast-paced lifestyle.

Beyond saving time, a sleek, walk-in shower can also give your bathroom a more elegant and spacious feel. It’s a big draw for homebuyers who are gunning for convenience and a contemporary look in their homes.

Additionally, showers are a great option for people with mobility issues. Stepping into a shower is much safer compared to climbing over the high wall of a bathtub. In 2021, falls among adults aged 65 and older resulted in over 38,000 deaths, making it the leading cause of injury-related death in this age group.

However, before you grab that sledgehammer to rip out your tub, think about how this change could affect your home’s resale value. While showers offer many benefits, the lack of a bathtub might not appeal to every buyer.

The Impact on Different Demographics: Families vs. Singles and Seniors

When thinking about resale value, consider who you’re looking to sell your home to. A bathtub-to-shower conversion could be a big plus for younger singles, couples, or seniors. Most of them often prefer the convenience and style of a walk-in shower.

On the other hand, if your home is in a family-friendly neighborhood, a tub-to-shower conversion could potentially be a drawback. Families with young children often see a bathtub as an essential feature. It provides a safe, easy space for bathing small children, and for many parents, it’s non-negotiable.

If most buyers in your area are families, keeping at least one bathtub in your home could be a smart choice. It makes your home more versatile and appealing to a broader range of buyers.

Real Estate Insights: How Does it Affect Home Value?

Real estate experts have mixed opinions about the impact of tub-to-shower conversion ideas on home value. Some believe it might narrow the pool of potential buyers. Others argue that a well-done shower conversion can boost a home’s value, particularly if the existing tub is outdated and the new shower has a modern, high-end design.

When a Tub-to-Shower Conversion Makes Sense

A tub-to-shower conversion might be just what your home needs, but it’s not always the best choice for everyone.  Whether a tub-to-shower conversion is right for you depends on your situation, your home’s setup, and what buyers in your area are looking for. Here are a few scenarios where making the switch could be a smart move.

1. You Have Multiple Bathrooms

If your home has more than one bathroom, you’ve got some flexibility! Converting one tub into a shower gives you the best of both worlds- you keep a tub in one bathroom for those who want it, and you get a modern, easy-to-use shower in another.

2. The Existing Tub is Outdated or Damaged

Do you have an old, chipped, or outdated tub that’s seen better days? Replacing it with a fresh, new shower, can breathe new life into the space. It’s a great way to boost your bathroom’s appeal and make it more attractive to buyers who want a move-in-ready home.

3. Your Home is In a Market that Favors Showers

If you’re in a neighborhood that’s popular with retirees, or you’re aiming to attract older buyers, a walk-in shower is often a big selling point. It’s safer, more accessible, and just easier to use.

DIY vs. Professional Conversions: What’s Best for Resale Value?

You might be tempted to save some money and convert your tub to a shower yourself, but think carefully about this decision. Although DIY can save money upfront, it’s also a bit risky, especially if you don’t have experience with plumbing, tiling, or general bathroom construction.  

A botched conversion could lead to serious issues like leaks, water damage, or mold. Besides costing you more in repairs, these problems can also scare off potential buyers when it’s time to sell.

On the other hand, hiring a professional tub-to-shower conversion contractor might cost upfront, but it’s an investment in your home’s value and long-term durability. You won’t have to worry about potential buyers pointing out flaws or requesting price cuts because the job wasn’t done properly.

Put simply, choosing a professional could save you time, money, and headaches while increasing your chances of getting a better selling price.

Final Thoughts: To Convert or Not to Convert?

So, will a tub-to-shower conversion hurt your resale value? 

The honest answer is that it depends. The effect on your home’s value comes down to who your potential buyers are and the market you’re in.

Whatever you decide, make sure the renovation is high-quality. A poorly executed conversion, whether it’s a tub or a shower, can hurt your resale value. Focus on what appeals to your potential buyers and make thoughtful choices that enhance your bathroom’s functionality and style.

After all, the bathroom is a key selling point in any home, so it’s important to make upgrades that add value and make a lasting impression.

The Bottom Line

In the end, the choice to convert a tub to a shower should be based on your personal needs and the market you’re in. Weigh the pros and cons carefully, consider your potential buyers, and don’t skimp on quality. A well-thought-out conversion can make your home more appealing and even boost its value.

Transform your outdated tub into a sleek, modern shower with Lifespan Bath Remodel! Schedule your consultation today and start creating the bathroom you’ve always wanted.